Scout.com > Washington Early Forecast Story URL: http://was.scout.com/2/786525.html Site Staff WarpathInsiders.com Sep 3, 2008 Who is going to be the best player this year on offense? How about defense? The best rookie? Who will have the most disappointing season? All these picks and more are right here. Our picks for: Offensive player of the year: Clinton Portis Defensive player of the year: Andre Carter Top rookie: Lord, this one is hard despite having 10 draft picks on the roster. Gotta be Durant Brooks. Next best: Chris Horton Who will have more catches, the rookie WRs or James Thrash: Thrash. Maybe the big questions is can Devin Thomas break double digits. Top newcomer: Jason Taylor Best comeback: Carlos Rogers Most disappointing season: Fred Smoot Most yards receiving: Santana Moss Most catches: Chris Cooley Most likely to be benched: Reed Doughty Copyright © Scout.com and WarpathInsiders.com